hi
now there's the new jpg folder, which is nice, but it's jpg, so no transparency channel, which a png would have. now i could mask the jpg sequence of course with another jpg sequence, but as far as i remember, having one with an alpha channel runs faster, than one without one and a mask instead. soo.. would a png-folder be a legitimate feature request, or did i oversee something?
jpg folder masking vs png folder
-
- Posts: 12
- Joined: Sat Feb 27, 2016 3:56 pm
Re: jpg folder masking vs png folder
I second that, transparent .png folders/sequences would be great and I was surprised that it's not possible. Is there some technical reason for it?
Re: jpg folder masking vs png folder
Here's a bit of an explanation: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=678&p=2992#p2997
I can certainly look into creating a "PngFolder" module at some point, but just be aware that the real-time performance wouldn't be very good.
I can certainly look into creating a "PngFolder" module at some point, but just be aware that the real-time performance wouldn't be very good.
Re: jpg folder masking vs png folder
but would it be worse than when we would use a mask-sequence in addition to the jpg sequence?Eric wrote:but just be aware that the real-time performance wouldn't be very good.
Re: jpg folder masking vs png folder
I think so. It depends on each situation, but I did run some tests with .png sequences a while ago, and the maximum speed was several times slower than with .jpg's. For .jpg's, the file sizes are smaller, and most of the decoding work is done with hardware acceleration on the CPU/GPU. For .png's , no hardware acceleration of any kind can be used.
One thing you can do to make a .jpg mask even faster is save it as grayscale so it's 1/3 of the size. It will be read from disk and decoded more efficiently.
One thing you can do to make a .jpg mask even faster is save it as grayscale so it's 1/3 of the size. It will be read from disk and decoded more efficiently.
Re: jpg folder masking vs png folder
okay, jpgs it is then. thanks for confirming.
Re: jpg folder masking vs png folder
Also, you can convert your png sequences to .mov files while maintaining alpha.
I use FFMPEG to do it. That's been my workaround.
I use FFMPEG to do it. That's been my workaround.